Skip to Main Content
Stony Brook University

WRT 102

Use this guide to help you find research and writing processes that work for you!

Comparing "peer-reviewed" journals with "popular" periodicals

 

Peer-reviewed journals

 

Newspapers and magazines

 

Authors

experts in specific fields

journalists, reporters, opinion writers

Audience

other experts, researchers, academics / professors, and students

general / non-professionals

Purpose

for experts to communicate with other experts and advance knowledge in a subject or field

to educate the general public and generate revenue

Reference List

comprehensive

minimal or none

Process

articles are selected based on rigorous peer-review process; publication process is slow

articles are selected based on review by editors; publication process is fast

Advertisements

Few or none

many

Writing Style

Written in the technical language of the field

Written in non-technical language and for the general public

What are peer-reviewed journal articles?

When we talk about different types of information formats, we are talking about the different types of containers that information comes in. Examples of formats include a blog post, a newspaper article, a YouTube video, a tweet, a painting, a poem, and a peer-reviewed journal article. None of these types of formats is inherently better or worse than any other, but you want to choose information in a format that is appropriate to whatever your project is.  Writing an academic research paper is a different project than writing on a blog, for example.

When you are writing a research paper, many of your professors will require that you use "peer-reviewed" or "scholarly" or "academic" journal articles because this format tells us that the information was created by an expert in a specific field, reviewed and accepted by that expert's peers (more experts), and read by and discussed among a community of experts. Scholarship can be like a conversation between experts in a specific field, and reading a peer-reviewed journal article is one way to "listen in on" such a conversation. Use the journal title to help you understand what type of "conversation" goes on in that journal. 

The comparison graphic above explains how a peer-reviewed journal article is different from an article in a magazine or newspaper. Both formats are equally useful, but they have different purposes and go through different creation processes.  When evaluating sources, it is always helpful to understand what the "format" -- like a newspaper article or a peer-reviewed journal article -- can tell us about the information, and what the creation process is for that particular format.

What is the peer-review process?

Watch this short video created by NCSU to better understand the peer review process:

Peer Review in Three Minutes